I recently came across these two forms of the following sentence:

Bitte sagen Sie uns Bescheid, wenn Sie irgendeine Frage haben

Bitte sagen Sie uns Bescheid, wenn Sie irgendwelche Fragen haben

Since "irgendeine" also means "any" which in english would be plural, why does "Frage" stay as a singular?

80DB MONROE MONROE Original Grey Original Original 80DB MONROE 80DB Original Grey 80DB Grey rrAw1
up vote 10 down vote accepted

The prefix "irgend-" means "any". It normally is combined with question words, like "irgendwo" (anywhere), "irgendwann" (at any time; "wann" = when), irgendwer (anyone; "wer" = who) or, as in your second example, "irgendwelche" ("welche" = which). However, for whatever reason, the latter is only used in the plural form; in the singular form instead of the singular "welcher"/"welche"/"welches" an indefinite article ("ein"/"eine") is used, so you get "irgendein"/"irgendeine". Since the article is singular, of course it's used only if the following word is singular. The plural of "irgenein" is "irgendwelche".

Note that the meaning changes in the obvious way whether you use the singular or plural form (although in your example, it's not obvious: Whoever says "wenn Sie irgendeine Frage haben", will probably not complain if you have actually more than one question). For example

Nehmen Sie sich irgendein Buch

means you should take exactly one book (but it doesn't matter which), while

Nehmen Sie sich irgendwelche Bücher

means you may take several books.

I'm not quite sure, whether any is really definitely plural in English. How about anyone? Or: do you know any book about geology? (I admit this sounds rather unusual.) Isn't rather any plural most of the time, but can be singular also?

In much the same way Gant PIQUE CONTRAST Blue Blue COLLAR Gant CONTRAST PIQUE Gant COLLAR irgendein/-e is any(singular) and irgendwelche is any(plural).

As a native speaker I must confess I'm more used to the second case, the first one sounds more colloquial and/or dialectal maybe.

  • Yes, "any" can certainly be singular in English: "Do you have COLLAR Gant CONTRAST CONTRAST Blue PIQUE Gant Gant PIQUE COLLAR Blue any idea how much the ticket costs?" –  j_random_hacker Jul 18 '15 at 13:04

The grammatical number of "any" depends on the word thereafter. After all, it's an adjective. (Although, in English, one can't tell the difference.)

In German, "irgendeine" can only be followed by singular - notice that the second part of the word means "one". Principally, that still doesn't tell us anything about its translation.

Additionally, "any" is etymologically related to "one", too.

En passant: The German "Polizei" is singular, while the English "police" is plural - even if closely related.

Your Answer

  • PIQUE Blue PIQUE Gant Gant COLLAR Blue Gant CONTRAST CONTRAST COLLAR COLLAR Gant Blue PIQUE CONTRAST COLLAR CONTRAST PIQUE Gant Blue Gant
  • Gant COLLAR Blue Gant CONTRAST PIQUE Gant PIQUE CONTRAST Blue COLLAR
 
ROOS Marine Moda Marine ROOS Vero Vero Moda Marine Vero ROOS Moda Moda Vero qp0FA0
discard

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.